The latest reviews for Alone in the Dark (2024) have left critics divided, with opinions ranging from extreme praise to severe criticism. While some reviewers have commended the game’s storytelling and puzzles, others have found it to be tedious and frustrating. The combat system and various bugs within the game have been highlighted as major issues, leading to a wide spectrum of ratings from 8.5/10 to one star. It seems that Alone in the Dark (2024) will be a love it or hate it experience, with major discrepancies in its reception.
In a scathing review by The Guardian’s critic, Rick Lane, Alone in the Dark (2024) was criticized for its poor writing and buggy combat. Lane described the remake as dull and uninteresting, lacking the personality of the original game. He pointed out similarities to Capcom’s Resident Evil 2 remake but noted a lack of attention to detail and finesse. While the game’s setting and puzzles were deemed mildly diverting, Lane ultimately found Alone in the Dark to be deeply tedious. The performances of Jodie Comer and David Harbour were also called out for being tonally off and lacking authenticity.
On the other end of the spectrum, Press Start Australia’s critic, James Berich, offered a more positive take on Alone in the Dark (2024). Berich found the game uniquely charming and appreciated the twists on the original formula. Despite acknowledging issues with combat and enemy variety, Berich enjoyed the overall experience of the game. He found it compelling enough to play through multiple times, although lacking in the fear and terror that are typically associated with horror games. Berich highlighted the game’s replayability and significant narrative elements as redeeming qualities.
Mark Delaney from GameSpot critiqued Alone in the Dark (2024) for failing to do justice to its source material. He described the game as derivative and ceaselessly unenjoyable, particularly due to its combat mechanics. Delaney found the AI guiding enemies comical and likened melee combat to a directionless flail. While he appreciated some of the puzzle segments and exploration in the game, Delaney concluded that it fell short of expectations, especially in comparison to modern horror game remakes.
Eurogamer’s Review
Eurogamer’s critic, Vikki Blake, echoed criticisms of the game’s combat system, labeling it janky and unpolished. Blake expressed that every aspect of Alone in the Dark (2024) was plagued by issues, from combat to puzzles, sound, and script. While she acknowledged the game’s unique storytelling and narrative deviations, Blake found the overall experience to be mediocre and forgettable. Despite some redeeming qualities, particularly in the overarching vision and ideas, Blake’s review leaned towards the negative end of the spectrum.
PC Gamer’s Review
In contrast to the majority of critics, PC Gamer’s Alexander Chatziioannou had a highly positive experience with Alone in the Dark (2024). He praised the game’s atmosphere, callbacks to the original, and compelling horror story twists. Chatziioannou had particularly high praise for the dialogue and performances, citing chemistry between the main characters as natural and engaging. He appreciated the writing style, describing it as “Lynchian” in its sense of disconnect and strangeness. Despite acknowledging bugs in the game, Chatziioannou deemed Alone in the Dark (2024) a resounding success, made with intelligence and a genuine love for the series.
The critical reception of Alone in the Dark (2024) is mixed, with some reviewers highlighting its strengths in storytelling and atmosphere, while others criticize its combat mechanics and lack of originality. The game seems to evoke strong emotions from players, with opinions ranging from adoration to disappointment. Ultimately, Alone in the Dark (2024) may be a polarizing experience that resonates differently with each player.
Leave a Reply